Terry's Pizza Shoppe

Terry's Pizza Shoppe, located at 433 W State St in Newcomerstown, OH, is a beloved staple in the community, drawing in both locals and visitors alike with its homey atmosphere and delicious offerings. Regulars praise the pizza as the best they’ve enjoyed, with nostalgic memories of shared meals that span decades. Customers like Brock Gamble and Capri Newman reflect on their long-standing ties to the shop, highlighting not only the quality of the food but also the warmth of the people behind it.

The dining experience is characterized by generous portions at reasonable prices, making it a great value, as noted by Sara Tomlinson, who appreciated the accommodating service when making special requests. Whether dining in or opting for timely delivery, guests are treated with kindness, as evidenced by the personal touch from owner Terry, who ensures everyone feels right at home.

While the shop has faced some challenges, the consistency of their tasty pizza and wings, along with the continued commitment of its staff, keeps patrons coming back. In a world full of fleeting trends, Terry's Pizza Shoppe remains a steadfast choice for comfort food, community connection, and cherished memories. It's truly a gem worth revisiting, promising more delightful meals to come.